This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Where to Stay: New York Islands

The 14 Dreamiest Island Airbnbs for Weekend Trips From NYC

Summer in New York City is a lot. By June, even the most die-hard locals are planning their next escape — and some of the easiest getaways are just across the water. There’s a whole lineup of nearby islands worth visiting, not just for a quick swim but for a full weekend away.

Here are our favorite islands near New York City — and the best places to stay on each.

Fire Island: Secluded Fire Island retreat with panoramic dune and ocean views
Aquidneck Island: Three-bedroom with private beach access in Portsmouth
Martha's Vineyard: Luxury five-bedroom retreat with water views and private pool in West Tisbury
Long Beach Island: Waterfront four-bedroom in Ship Bottom with private dock and rooftop deck
Nantucket: Elegant six-bedroom home near Nantucket’s Historic District with room for the whole group
Shelter Island: Waterfront estate with private beach, dock, and panoramic bay views

Viral Videos

moving bed in a rental

Cabin

A remote cabin in Remsen that lets you sleep under the stars.

dog staying at the Plaza

Hotel

Because your pup deserves a suite at the Plaza, too.

GuideGeek

Planning a Trip? Ask GuideGeek®.

A new (free) way to plan and book travel seamlessly in seconds.

Open on WhatsApp
Open on Messenger
Open on Instagram

/

Here at Matador, we're always looking for the best travel deals. We may receive a commission via affiliate links in this newsletter. Prices and availability can change at any time.

EXPLORE THE WORLD WITH MATADOR

FOLLOW US HERE