Epic Stays: The 14 Dreamiest Island Airbnbs

For weekend trips from NYC

Where to Stay: New York Islands

The 14 Dreamiest Island Airbnbs for Weekend Trips From NYC

Summer in New York City is a lot. By June, even the most die-hard locals are planning their next escape — and some of the easiest getaways are just across the water. There’s a whole lineup of nearby islands worth visiting, not just for a quick swim but for a full weekend away.

Here are our favorite islands near New York City — and the best places to stay on each.

Fire Island: Secluded Fire Island retreat with panoramic dune and ocean views
Aquidneck Island: Three-bedroom with private beach access in Portsmouth
Martha's Vineyard: Luxury five-bedroom retreat with water views and private pool in West Tisbury
Long Beach Island: Waterfront four-bedroom in Ship Bottom with private dock and rooftop deck
Nantucket: Elegant six-bedroom home near Nantucket’s Historic District with room for the whole group
Shelter Island: Waterfront estate with private beach, dock, and panoramic bay views

Want More?

Check out more favorite New York summer getaways.

Follow Us

For more Epic Stays here.

Matador TikTok

Matador instagram

Viral Videos

moving bed in a rental

Cabin

A remote cabin in Remsen that lets you sleep under the stars.

dog staying at the Plaza

Hotel

Because your pup deserves a suite at the Plaza, too.

GuideGeek

Planning a Trip? Ask GuideGeek®.

A new (free) way to plan and book travel seamlessly in seconds.

Open on WhatsApp
Open on Messenger
Open on Instagram

/

Here at Matador, we're always looking for the best travel deals. We may receive a commission via affiliate links in this newsletter. Prices and availability can change at any time.

EXPLORE THE WORLD WITH MATADOR

FOLLOW US HERE

Reply

or to participate.